I guess every director in entitled to directing a dud once in a while. This is Gulzar’s dud.
An ambitious woman politician who sleeps with her political mentor to ease her way upwards, a daughter who is antithetical in her ways, political adversaries and games they play and how karma catches up………is what its all about.
Great actors, Tabu and Nana fall flat on a script that tries too hard to please. Almost all aspects of film-making are so ordinary that the overall impact would have been pretty forgettable had it not been for the fact that it’s so painful to watch Tabu deliver a below-par performance
In fact I have a deep suspicion that this movie has been ghost directed by Meghna Gulzar (Gulzar’s daughter and officially the associate screenplay writer)
And even that rarest of rare event occurs: Lata’s voice is so very discordant. Its difficult to make a call whether she has just not caught on to the mood of the song, of whether she was the wrong choice of singer for the face on-screen.
Vishal’s Marathi touches to the songs are superficial if not downright condescending. Having seen his other movie ‘Kaminey’ and its treatment of the Marathi angle, I am more inclined in favour of the latter.
• The more well-known song being 'Chai Chappa Chai' where both the male and female voices sound discordant when pictured on Sunil Shetty and Tabu.
What could have been a good street-play has been made into a bad movie
Gracy Singh (in a extremely insignificant role, in which she dances much better than Tabu)
Playback: Lata, Hariharan, Roopkumar Rathod, Anuradha Paudwal, Kavita Krishnamurthy, Suresh Wadkar, Vinay Mandke
Associate Screenplay Writer: Meghna Gulzar
Audiography: Narinder Singh
Cinematography: Manmohan Singh
Produced by Dhirajlal Shah
Written and Directed by Gulzar
Favorites of 2017: Nonfiction - *B. G. MacCarthy:* *The Female Pen: Women Writers and Novelists 1621-1818* (NYU Press, 1994) This book and the one that follows helped shape my 2017 fict...
22 hours ago